ITNº 47Food & Beverage Trade

Mondelez sues vegan chocolatier Catherine's Originals over Toblerone shape

Mondelez has sued vegan brand Catherine's Originals at the UK High Court, claiming its £9.20 O'Bar infringes the Toblerone prism shape trademarked in 1994.

· 2 min at the table

Toblerone owner Mondelez sues British vegan chocolate brand Catherine’s Originals, claiming trademark infringement
Toblerone owner Mondelez sues British vegan chocolate brand Catherine’s Originals, claiming trademark infringementAI-generated

Menu du jour

  1. First course

    Mondelez filed a trademark claim against Catherine's Originals at the UK High Court over the O'Bar's shape.

  2. Second course

    The Toblerone prism shape has been trademarked in the UK since 1994.

  3. Third course

    Catherine's Originals' 200g O'Bar costs £9.20–£10.55 versus roughly £4.20 for a 200g Toblerone.

  4. Fourth course

    Mondelez sued Aldi in Illinois last year over Oreo and Belvita packaging designs.

  5. Fifth course

    Founder Catherine Dodd says the O'Bar's rounded segments represent the 'O' in 'Originals'.

Mondelez International has filed a trademark infringement claim at the UK High Court in London against British vegan chocolatier Catherine's Originals, alleging that the shape of its plant-based O'Bar copies the Toblerone prism.

The Toblerone silhouette – chunky triangular peaks inspired by the Swiss Alps – has carried trademark protection in the UK since 1994. Mondelez argues that the O'Bar, a long, flat bar topped with oval-shaped segments, comes too close to that registered shape.

Who are the parties?

Catherine's Originals is a small West Sussex brand selling dairy-free chocolate. The O'Bar range runs from an original dark chocolate and plant-based milk and white variants to flavours such as Pumpkin Spice and Cookie No Crumble. The vegan milk version contains vegan honeycomb pieces and blanched almonds; the original Toblerone contains honey and almond nougat.

The price gap between the two products is wide. Catherine's Originals' 200g sharing bar starts at £9.20, with special flavours costing up to £10.55. A 200g Toblerone bar typically retails at around £4.20.

What does the lawsuit argue?

Laurie Bray, senior associate trade mark attorney at European IP firm Withers & Rogers, called the case fairly unique.

"It's quite rare for a brand owner to sue another over the shape of one its products," she said. "Even with a trademark registration in place protecting the shape of its Toblerone chocolate bar, it could be challenging for Mondelez to prove that the bar made by Catherine's Originals is sufficiently similar in shape that it would cause customer confusion."

Bray added that commercial protection for a product's shape alone is difficult to obtain, but remains "worth considering" as brands confront 'dupe culture' – consumers seeking lower-cost copies of premium goods. Catherine's Originals does not fit that bracket: its bars sell at more than double Toblerone's retail price.

According to The Guardian, founder Catherine Dodd strongly disputes the claims. She says the bar's rounded segments represent the 'O' in 'Originals' from the brand's name.

Is this part of a pattern?

Mondelez, headquartered in the US, has pursued copycat claims before. Last year it sued retail chain Aldi in an Illinois court, alleging the discounter copied packaging designs for several of its cookie and cracker brands, including Oreo and Belvita.

The Toblerone action differs in one respect: it targets the shape of the product itself, not its packaging.

FoodBev has approached both Mondelez International and Catherine's Originals for comment.

For European confectionery operators, the case will clarify how far 3D shape trademarks stretch against small premium producers – and whether price positioning and segment design can defeat a confusion claim. The High Court filing now proceeds to Mondelez's evidence on likelihood of confusion, with Catherine's Originals' defence to follow.

via FoodBev (Source)

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in European hospitality industry at Eurotables Report.

128 articles

Other tables tonight

« Previous tableNext table »