ESNº 31Hotels & Groups
Scotland's £17.5bn tourism sector weighs visitor levy and AI bookings
Scotland's £17.5bn tourism sector heard calls to collaborate on demand, scrap VAT on the visitor levy, and prepare for AI-driven bookings at an STA and HotelPartner webinar.
· 4 min at the table

Scotland's tourism industry is worth £17.5bn and ranks as the country's largest direct employer, according to Scottish Tourism Alliance chief executive Marc Crothall MBE, who urged hoteliers to collaborate rather than compete for the same demand in a webinar hosted by the STA and HotelPartner Revenue & Profit Management, "The future of profitable hospitality in Scotland".
The session put two pressures on the table: the spread of the visitor levy beyond Edinburgh, and the rise of AI-driven hotel bookings.
What does the visitor levy change for operators?
Edinburgh's visitor levy is already live, and other local authorities plan to extend the charge across the country. Aberdeen hoteliers faced a 7% addition to bills. Stephen Gow, General Manager of The Chester Hotel, Aberdeen, said operators there chose cooperation over resistance.
"In Aberdeen did we want to add 7% to our bills? No we did not, but it was happening so we decided to work with the council as much as we could instead of working against them," Gow said. "I think in two or three years time we won't be talking about it, it will just be something we do."
Crothall stressed transparency on how levy revenue is spent, and flagged what the industry does not yet know. "We don't have hard evidence of the spending impact on visitors, where we are likely to see an impact will be the domestic market; we have seen an uptick in demand in destinations such as Glasgow, but whether that is the levy we don't know," he said.
He framed Edinburgh's charge as tolerable but quality-sensitive: "For Edinburgh it won't be a deterrent, but the guest will challenge quality more; you don't know when the bubble is going to burst." Levy income has funded police and lighting, which he called wise, while questioning whether that spending should have come from existing budgets.
His caveat for councils was blunt. Wage costs and VAT are already pushing prices up, and "guests may vote with their feet". He pointed to a contrast with competitor destinations: "In Venice and Barcelona they are trying to curtail visitors whereas we are trying to encourage them." His ask: "Local authorities should be open to flexing where they can; if you have no guests you have no levy."
One specific ask from the STA is fiscal. Crothall called for VAT to be removed from the levy itself, citing the zero rate applied to electricity as precedent. He conceded it is "a small token" and, given pressure on the public purse, said he does not expect wider VAT change.
Spreading demand beyond the central belt
Gow argued growth now requires deliberate selling, not open doors. "When I first came here we opened the doors and that's all you had to do. Those days are long gone," he said, noting growing guest numbers from the US.
"There is life outside the central belt and life outside Edinburgh. Certain parts of Scotland are at capacity some of the time; we're stronger if we collaborate, there's enough for all of us," Gow said.
Crothall put a figure on Scotland's international draw: music and festivals account for £850m of revenue. "Our international audience stay longer and spend more and are critical for the industry," he said, adding that the STA is lobbying government for a pool of cash on the basis that tourism is an export industry.
Is AI a booking channel hotels must master?
Craig Burns, chairman of Huck Agency, said AI search is eroding Google's share and delivering results: "We're starting to see some big bookings through AI, the conversion rate is much higher, but not all of the market is ready to move over to it." His advice was direct: optimise for question-based search, because "AI is going to be a key channel so should be a focus for every hotel".
Robert Holland, managing director UK & Ireland at HotelPartner, said the company is working to ensure its hotels have visibility in AI chat, and argued revenue and marketing teams must work more closely. "Strong demand alone won't protect profits, it depends on how hotels manage their marketing and distribution," he said.
On cost relief through technology, Gow counselled diagnosis before purchase, and disclosed one failed experiment: his hotel removed self check-in and phone keys because so few guests used them. Holland agreed, adding that automation should strip tedious tasks from customer-facing staff.
What happens next: more Scottish local authorities are expected to adopt the visitor levy, the STA continues lobbying on VAT treatment of the charge, and operators face the practical work of making their inventory answer questions posed to AI agents rather than to Google.
via hotel-online.com (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in European hospitality industry at Eurotables Report.
137 articles
Other tables tonight
- Nº 03European Hospitality Operator Signs Edinburgh Management DealFROctober 10, 2026
- Nº 01London and Edinburgh still top UK hotel investment – DeloitteDEOctober 18, 2026
- Nº 31Hotels Face Four-Front Regulatory Squeeze on Rates, Wages and LeviesESNovember 17, 2026
- Nº 27Blantyre Capital Puts Crerar Hotels Up for Sale at GBP90 MillionITNovember 5, 2026
- Nº 22Scottish hospitality leaders demand VAT cut to save sectorITOctober 11, 2026