ESNº 14EU Policy & Regulation

EU postpones vote on Brazilian chicken ban despite clean audit

EU member states delayed a vote on lifting the Brazilian chicken import ban until early December, demanding clarity on Brazil's antimicrobial compliance despite a positive September audit.

· 2 min at the table

Brazilian chicken ban: EU delays decision despite positive audit
Brazilian chicken ban: EU delays decision despite positive auditkakyusei / pixabay

Menu du jour

  1. First course

    EU member states postponed the vote on lifting the Brazilian chicken ban on Tuesday, with a new meeting set for early December.

  2. Second course

    The September ban covers beef, poultry, eggs and honey, following a national experts' vote in May.

  3. Third course

    An EU audit in early September found Brazil's poultry control system operating effectively.

  4. Fourth course

    Mercosur caps tariff-free poultry at 180,000 tonnes (1.3% of EU output) and beef at 99,000 tonnes at a 7.5% tariff (1.5% of EU production).

  5. Fifth course

    The European Parliament referred the Mercosur deal to the Court of Justice of the EU over legality questions.

The 27 EU member states postponed Tuesday's vote on lifting the ban on Brazilian chicken imports after several countries demanded clarification from the European Commission on Brazil's compliance with EU antimicrobial rules.

The delay comes despite an EU audit in early September that found Brazil's poultry control system operating effectively. The ban itself, covering beef, poultry, eggs and honey, took effect in September following a vote by national experts in May. It was triggered by Brazil's use of antimicrobials to stimulate animal growth.

"A number of Member States requested further clarifications on the system put in place by Brazil," Commission spokesperson Eva Hrncirova said. The Commission will now "take the time to address these comments and questions" before a new meeting in early December.

Why does the ban matter to operators?

The standoff lands months after the contentious Mercosur trade deal with Latin American countries provisionally entered into force, opening trade in agricultural products including Brazilian meat. Brasilia reacted angrily to the ban, which it sees as undermining a deal only just implemented.

For European food service operators and wholesalers, the outcome shapes poultry supply and pricing. The Mercosur agreement caps tariff-free poultry access at 180,000 tonnes a year, or 1.3% of EU output. Beef imports are limited to 99,000 tonnes annually at a reduced 7.5% tariff — roughly 1.5% of EU production.

Who is pushing back, and why?

France leads several member states strongly opposed to the Mercosur agreement, signed in January this year. EU farmers fear dumping from the four signatories — Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay — citing lower production standards, particularly on health and phytosanitary rules.

The quota caps on sensitive agricultural products were written into the deal to answer those concerns. Ratification, however, remains stalled: the European Parliament referred the agreement to the Court of Justice of the European Union over questions about its legality.

Under pressure from Mercosur countries and EU backers of the deal, notably Spain and Germany, the Commission decided in May to provisionally implement the agreement pending the court's ruling.

What is not settled

The Commission has not published the audit's full findings in Tuesday's discussion, nor has it detailed which member states asked the questions or what specifically they want clarified about Brazil's antimicrobial system. A clean audit plus a postponed vote signals that technical findings and political appetite are moving at different speeds.

The timing also matters. A December decision would arrive as the Court of Justice weighs the deal's legality, meaning any lifting of the chicken ban could still be overtaken by the broader legal process.

The Commission now prepares its clarifications for the early December meeting. If member states accept them, the vote could reopen EU doors to Brazilian poultry within the 180,000-tonne annual cap; if not, the ban stays and the Mercosur friction deepens.

via euronews.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in European hospitality industry at Eurotables Report.

137 articles

Other tables tonight

« Previous tableNext table »