ESNº 18Hotels & Groups

Cornish MP's Bill Would Force Planning Permission for Second Homes

Andrew George's Homes and Planning Bill demands planning permission for second homes and holiday lets, as he claims rate relief cost Cornwall £500m since 2012.

· 3 min at the table

Permanent residences ‘desperately needed’, Cornish MP tells Commons
Permanent residences ‘desperately needed’, Cornish MP tells CommonsSylwesterL / pixabay

Menu du jour

  1. First course

    The Homes and Planning Bill would require planning permission to convert homes into second homes or short-term lets

  2. Second course

    Business rate relief on holiday lets has cost Cornwall £500m since 2012, Andrew George said

  3. Third course

    The rateable-value exemption threshold rises from £12,000 to £18,000 next year after the Budget

  4. Fourth course

    The Bill's second reading is due on Friday, with Labour expected to block it

  5. Fifth course

    Councils would gain powers to cap the number or proportion of second homes and holiday lets

A private member's Bill before the House of Commons would force homeowners to secure planning permission before turning houses into second homes or short-term holiday lets. Andrew George, Liberal Democrat MP for St Ives, opened the debate on his Homes and Planning Bill, warning that Labour may block its second reading on Friday and halt its passage through Parliament.

Mr George said some communities faced "a risk of proliferation of properties which are desperately needed for permanent occupancy, which are ebbing away from the local community and going for non-permanent use". The Bill targets English seaside counties, above all Cornwall, where he says there is a "desperate housing need".

What would the Bill change?

Under the proposals, homeowners would need planning permission in two cases: to convert a house into a private second home, and to offer a property as a short-term holiday let. Councils would gain the power to cap the "number or proportion" of houses used as either second homes or short-term lets. The Bill would also create separate planning classes for the two uses, plus new compulsory-purchase powers letting councils buy land for social housing.

How big is the tax distortion?

At the centre of the debate sits an existing arrangement. Homeowners can pay business rates instead of council tax if their second home is available for short-term lets at least 140 nights a year and actually let for at least 70 nights. A single property with a rateable value below £12,000 pays no business rates at all — and last month's Budget raised that threshold to £18,000 from next year, making the relief more generous.

Mr George told MPs the relief had cost Cornwall "half a billion pounds in taxpayers' money" since 2012. He said it subsidises "people who are wealthy enough to have a second home, enjoy their second home, who don't live in the area, who let it out to the holiday trade" — while local authorities lack money for the thousands of families facing a housing crisis. He asked: "Should they have been entitled to that? It's a moral question which one might want to ask."

Licensing or planning — which lever works?

Labour MP Markus Campbell-Savours, whose Penrith and Solway seat includes part of the Lake District, intervened with a rival approach. He doubted the planning system could enforce George's change, arguing it is "arguably insufficiently funded" and doesn't give authorities the means to enforce decisions later. A licensing scheme, he said, would give councils income "and would give the people issuing licenses the ability to remove them if they have been given to inappropriate landlords" — and could come "with a cap" on permitted holiday homes.

George dismissed that as a "dressing on the side, quite frankly", predicting a licence would "only apply to holiday lets and not second homes" and so miss half the problem.

What did the government say?

Housing minister Matthew Pennycook steered away from the Bill itself. "One of the most effective ways that communities can shape development in their areas is to have up-to-date local plans in place," he said, noting Cornwall's local plan dates from 2016 and its infrastructure funding statement is also out of date. Cornwall is "taking steps very late in the day", he added.

The Bill's second reading is scheduled for Friday. If Labour whips against it, the Bill dies; if it advances, operators of short-term lets in Cornwall and other coastal markets face a new permission regime.

via cornwalllive.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around European hospitality industry at Eurotables Report.

136 articles

Other tables tonight

« Previous tableNext table »