ESNº 08Hotels & Groups

Booking.com Regulars Book a High-50% Share of Room Nights

Genius tiers 2 and 3 book a high-50% share of Booking.com room nights, yet masked emails make repeat guests look new. Direct guests return at 5.1%; OTA guests at 1.3%.

· 4 min at the table

The second booking: Your regular came back through Booking.com. Your system thinks she's new.
The second booking: Your regular came back through Booking.com. Your system thinks she's new.Neon Wang / unsplash

Menu du jour

  1. First course

    Genius level 2 and 3 members are just over 30% of active customers but book a high-50% share of Booking.com room nights.

  2. Second course

    Bookboost data on 2.2 million guests: direct-first guests return at 5.1%, OTA-first guests at 1.3%.

  3. Third course

    Since September 28, Booking.com reservations arrive without a phone number; emails are masked as @guest.booking.com aliases.

  4. Fourth course

    Over 850,000 properties had joined Genius by end-September 2025.

  5. Fifth course

    Marriott Bonvoy passed 295 million members at the end of June; Expedia retired One Key on July 28.

By Priya Raman

Travellers in the top two tiers of Booking.com's Genius loyalty programme generate a high-50% share of the platform's room nights, and every one of their bookings reaches an independent hotel under a fresh email address the property has never seen. The consequence is structural: independent operators pay OTA commission, at Genius-discounted rates, on repeat guests their own systems register as first-timers.

How big is the hidden-regulars problem?

The numbers come from Booking.com itself. Genius tiers two and three account for just over 30% of active customers, yet book more than half of all room nights. Both figures rose year on year, according to the company's first- and second-quarter 2026 earnings calls, and its 2026 proxy filing to the SEC confirms the same pattern for 2025. More than 850,000 properties had joined Genius by the end of September 2025.

Reaching Genius level 2 takes five stays in two years. Chief executive Glenn Fogel has spelled out what members do next: they book more often, cancel less, return more consistently, and book direct through the Booking.com app or site more often than other customers. These are precisely the behaviours an independent hotel wants to own itself.

Who funds the discount?

The traveller pays nothing to join Genius. The hotel funds the benefit. A participating property gives every member at least 10% off, can offer level 2 members up to 15% and level 3 members up to 20%, and can add free breakfast or a room upgrade. Booking.com then charges commission on the already-reduced price — the discount and the fee compound.

Booking.com argues Genius brings hotels demand they would not otherwise capture, rather than shifting demand they already had, and that Genius guests write more reviews and fill off-season rooms. That is the platform's reading of its own data, as it presented it. For the guest, the arithmetic is simple: her tenth booking through the app earns more than her second booking with any single hotel. She needs no disloyalty to a property, only loyalty to the app.

What does the guest data actually show?

The only large-scale count of repeat behaviour comes from Bookboost, a hotel guest-messaging and CRM vendor. Its study of 2.2 million guests at European hotel groups between 2024 and 2026 found that guests whose first booking was direct returned 5.1% of the time. Guests whose first booking came through an OTA returned 1.3% of the time. OTAs delivered 65% of first stays but only 32% of repeat stays.

Read that carefully. Bookboost does not disclose its matching method. If it relied on email addresses, an OTA guest returning under a new alias would count as new and the 1.3% would understate true repeat rates. Either way, the hotel's own screen shows the same result: the guests it can recognise as returning are overwhelmingly the ones who booked direct first.

Why can't hotel systems spot her?

Two policy choices explain it. Booking.com does not pass on guest email addresses; every reservation carries a unique alias ending in @guest.booking.com, with messages forwarded through it. Since September 28, reservations also arrive without a phone number. Booking.com cites privacy for the first measure and fraud prevention for the second.

Email and phone are what most property systems match on to identify returning guests. A Genius regular arriving for her third stay presents neither. Unless the desk recognises her face or the system matches on name alone, she checks in as new. Her preferred room, her anniversary, her noted allergy stay locked on a profile the system will not connect.

Are the chains running the same play?

Yes. Expedia retired its One Key programme on July 28, repaying travellers in OneKeyCash at every tier, while Hotels.com's new business travel mode surfaces a one-tap rebook for returning guests. Marriott reported Bonvoy passed 295 million members at the end of June. Each programme serves one purpose: keeping the second booking inside its own app.

The independent cannot match points. What it holds is the guest in the building for two or three nights, with no intermediary present.

What should operators do now?

Pull the repeat guest report for the past 12 months and verify it matches on name and check-in details, never email alone. Count repeat guests, then count how many returned via Booking.com, and total the commission paid on those stays — the cost of hosting people who already knew the property. At the desk, capture the real email address manually where the system will not retain it, and screen every Booking.com arrival against past guests by name. The hotels that act before the autumn booking cycle will keep more of their second bookings where they belong.

via hospitality.today (Original)

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in European hospitality industry at Eurotables Report.

139 articles

Other tables tonight

« Previous tableNext table »