ITNº 15Deals & Finance

£100,000 pledge pulled 24 hours after village pub hit its £490,000 target

A £100,000 pledge was withdrawn 24 hours after the £490,000 target was reached, leaving Ponsanooth's community buyout of the Stag Hunt pub six days to refill the gap or lose the pub.

· 3 min at the table

Community campaign to save village pub suffers unexpected blow after reaching funding target
Community campaign to save village pub suffers unexpected blow after reaching funding targetAI-generated

Menu du jour

  1. First course

    A £100,000 pledge was withdrawn on Monday after the £490,000 target was reached on Sunday night.

  2. Second course

    The share offer deadline is midnight on Thursday, November 19; missing it returns all funds and relists the pub.

  3. Third course

    The Stag Hunt dates to the early 1800s and sits in the Cornish Mining World Heritage Site.

  4. Fourth course

    Investors could commit between £100 and £40,000 under the all-or-nothing, 12-month community share offer.

  5. Fifth course

    £7,000 arrived on Friday, November 13, days after the withdrawal.

The Ponsanooth Community Benefit Society hit its £490,000 target to buy Cornwall's Stag Hunt pub on Sunday night — then lost £100,000 of it by email on Monday. The donor, who has no connection to the pub or the village, redirected the money to another rural social isolation project, chairman Sam Fitch confirmed. No contract existed because the sum was a pledge, not a signed commitment. That single distinction now threatens a 220-year-old asset in Ponsanooth, between Truro and Falmouth, inside the Cornish Mining World Heritage Site.

How a celebration became a shortfall

The sequence was compressed and brutal. A £10,000 investment on Sunday night pushed the community share offer over its £490,000 asking price. ITV News was booked to cover the milestone on Monday. Later that day the society received the email withdrawing the £100,000 pledge. "We were spinning," Fitch said.

He was careful about the donor's motives. "I'm trying hard not to be cross with them because they still want to do what we're trying to do which is good," Fitch said. "But it's taken me a while to be accepting. I'm trying not to be angry with them because it is a wealthy individual still trying to spend their own money on a good cause." The donor, he said, chose another cause that will equally relieve rural social isolation. What was not said in the withdrawal, by the society's own account, is any explanation of the timing — why the pledge held until the campaign appeared won.

What does this change for the campaign?

It restores a live funding gap with a hard deadline: midnight on Thursday, November 19. The share offer is structured all-or-nothing, with a 12-month limit. If the target is missed, every penny returns to investors and the freehold goes back on the open market, where residents fear conversion to housing. The gap is still closing — £7,000 arrived on the morning of Friday, November 13 — but replacing a single six-figure pledge with retail investments of £100 to £40,000 each is a different order of difficulty in under a week.

The asset and its ownership trail

The Stag Hunt dates to the early 1800s and is closely tied to the village's Kennall Vale gunpowder works. It serves Ponsanooth's real ale trade, pouring beer from local breweries Dynamite Valley and Treen, plus Penryn's Verdant. Wayne and Michelle Randall bought the pub in 2022 from former landlords Usha and Garry James. The previous owners, Fitch said in April, could not rebuild the business after Covid. "Running a pub like the Stag Hunt is a lifestyle so they sold it to Wayne and Michelle," he told CornwallLive. Under the Randalls the pub opened only three evenings a week, and residents mobilised when a sale to developers became the realistic exit.

The share offer has drawn money from investors in America and Australia with ancestral links to Cornwall — evidence of how far the pub's social franchise extends beyond the village. "It's been such a rollercoaster," Fitch said of the two-year campaign. "We've had the highest of the highs and the lowest of the lows. But we still believe and as long as there still is hope we will not let it die."

The caveat sits in the structure itself: pledges, as this week proved, are reversible until money clears. Community ownership models across the UK typically solve this with binding agreements at target, and the society has not explained whether it will change its pledging terms after this episode. Donations remain open at savethestag.co.uk. The next verified number arrives at midnight on November 19: target met, or the Stag Hunt relisted.

via cornwalllive.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in European hospitality industry at Eurotables Report.

137 articles

Other tables tonight

« Previous tableNext table »